Choosing and Managing a Business Broker
A broker or other intermediary is one of several ways to run a sale. Some owners sell directly, some engage an experienced intermediary, and many do some of both. What matters is that you choose deliberately, understand how the intermediary is paid, and keep responsibility for the decisions that are yours. This lesson is not for or against using a broker. It is about being the informed party in the conversation.
What an intermediary actually does
A broker is paid to run a sale process, not to be right about your business. Typical functions include pricing guidance, packaging the business, preparing marketing materials, confidential marketing, finding prospective buyers, screening buyers, coordinating confidentiality agreements, handling buyer questions, managing offers and negotiation, and coordinating the transaction with attorneys, accountants, lenders, and other professionals.
- Pricing and valuation guidance — where the business should be positioned, and why
- Packaging the business and preparing marketing materials
- Confidential marketing through blind listings, teasers, and direct outreach
- Finding prospective buyers, including buyers you would never reach yourself
- Screening buyers and coordinating confidentiality agreements
- Handling buyer questions and managing the flow of information
- Managing offers, negotiation, and competing buyers
- Coordinating with attorneys, accountants, lenders, and other professionals
- Keeping the process and the timeline moving
| Area | Usually the intermediary | Usually you | Others involved |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing and positioning | Recommends a range and the reasoning behind it | Decides what you will accept, and when | CPA, for normalized earnings |
| Marketing and buyer outreach | Builds the materials and works the buyer list | Reviews and approves what is released | Attorney, for confidentiality terms |
| Buyer screening and NDAs | Runs first contact and signs confidentiality agreements | Sets what may be shared, and with whom | Attorney, if an agreement is unusual |
| Offers and negotiation | Handles questions, competing offers, and the back and forth | Decides your terms, walk-away point, and structure | Attorney, for LOI and purchase agreement |
| Diligence coordination | Collects requests and keeps buyers organized | Answers operational and financial questions | CPA and attorney |
| Structure, tax, and legal | Explains what the market expects | Decides with qualified advisers, not with the broker | CPA and attorney |
Business broker, M&A advisor, or selling it yourself
In practice these labels describe size and scope more than law. A business broker usually works on smaller, Main Street transactions. An M&A advisor usually works on larger or more complex lower-middle-market transactions, with a longer process and fewer, more sophisticated buyers. Investment banks work above that. The label matters less than what this person actually does, how they find buyers, and what they have closed. Ask about the work, not the title.
- •Buyers are often individuals, existing operators, or local competitors
- •Marketing is usually broader and more visible
- •Processes tend to be shorter and less structured
- •Often priced on a multiple of SDE
- •Seller financing or bank financing is common
- •Buyers are often strategic acquirers or private equity
- •Outreach is targeted and quieter
- •Processes are longer and more structured
- •Priced on adjusted EBITDA and quality of earnings
- •Representations, escrows, and earnouts are common
Strategic buyers are companies in or near your industry, buying for capability, customers, territory, or talent. They can sometimes pay more than a financial buyer, because they can remove cost or add revenue. Financial buyers, including private equity, buy earnings and management depth, and they generally want a business that runs without you. Neither is better in general; each is better for a particular business.
- •Many buyers see a teaser or a listing
- •Broader reach through buyer lists and marketplaces
- •More inquiries to screen
- •Competition between buyers can raise the price
- •More people know, so confidentiality discipline matters
- •Only buyers you or your intermediary approach
- •Reasonable when you already know a credible buyer
- •Can be structured quietly and run quickly
- •Less competitive tension, so price discipline is on you
- •Still needs real diligence and real documentation
Selling directly can be reasonable when you already have a credible buyer, in a family transfer, in an employee or management transition, or in a carefully structured off-market transaction. It is equally reasonable to use an intermediary for marketing and negotiation while your attorney and CPA handle structure and tax. Plenty of good sales are a hybrid.
How intermediaries get paid
Compensation varies widely by transaction size, industry, region, and level of service. There is no universal commission percentage, and any figure presented as if there were one deserves a question. What you need is the shape of your own agreement, in writing.
- Success fee or commission — typically a percentage of the sale price, paid at closing
- Retainer — a periodic fee, sometimes credited against the success fee
- Upfront fee — paid at engagement, sometimes for work already done
- Minimum fee — a floor the success fee cannot fall below
- Tiered or scaled fees — a percentage that changes across price bands
- Expense reimbursement — marketing, travel, listing, or printing costs, capped or uncapped
- Co-broker or referral splits — when another intermediary represents the buyer
- Hourly or project fees — when you buy advice or preparation work without an engagement
- What exactly is owed, and on what amount is it calculated?
- When is it owed — at closing, at signing, or on a schedule?
- Does the amount change with the sale price or the deal structure?
- If I find the buyer myself, is a fee still owed, and how much?
- What happens if the business does not sell at all?
- Do fee obligations survive the end of the agreement, and for how long?
- Are expenses capped, pre-approved, and documented?
Your interests and your intermediary’s interests
They usually overlap. A completed transaction at a fair price is good for both of you, and a good intermediary makes your process better: more buyers, stronger negotiation, and a deal that stays on track. But they are not identical, and the differences are worth understanding well before you are mid-negotiation.
- •Maximum net proceeds after fees and taxes
- •The right buyer for your customers and employees
- •Protecting the people who work for you
- •Confidentiality and local reputation
- •Legacy, family, and community
- •Deal structure and cash at closing
- •Limiting your seller-financing exposure
- •Certainty that the deal actually closes
- •Timing: not too early, not too late
- •Taxes and your retirement
- •Being able to move on, in your own way
- •Winning the listing
- •Getting the business sold
- •Getting the transaction closed
- •Earning the success fee
- •Not spending disproportionate time on a business that may never sell
- •Building a track record and future referrals
- •Maintaining standing with the buyers they work with repeatedly
- My minimum acceptable net proceeds, after fees, debt payoff, and taxes
- How much cash I need at closing, and by when
- How much seller financing or earnout risk I will carry, and on what terms
- What I am not willing to do: stay beyond a set period, take an employment role, hold rollover I cannot sell
- The buyer characteristics that matter to me: employees retained, location kept, customers treated well
- The timeline I am working toward, and the date after which I would rather not sell
The engagement agreement: what to settle before you sign
An engagement agreement is a contract, and the version a broker hands you is usually drafted to protect the broker. It is not a formality. Have your own attorney review it before you sign, and treat the discussion of terms as a normal part of the negotiation rather than an awkward one.
- Exclusive or non-exclusive: who else may market or sell your business during the term
- Term length, and whether it renews automatically
- Your termination rights: what notice you must give, and what it costs you
- The tail, or protection, period: how long a fee can still be owed after termination, and on which buyers
- Buyers introduced during the term, and how that list is recorded
- Buyers you find yourself, and whether they are excluded from the fee
- The fee amount, the basis it is calculated on, and when it becomes payable
- Expenses: what is reimbursable, whether there is a cap, and whether approval is required
- Confidentiality obligations in both directions: what may be shared, and with whom
- Marketing permissions: whether your business may be advertised, named, described, or photographed, and where
How to interview intermediaries
Interview at least two or three. Pay attention to how they answer, not only to what they promise: specific numbers, named comparable transactions, and a clear process beat enthusiasm. Expect the conversation to include real questions back to you about your financials and your goals.
- What size and type of businesses do you sell most often?
- How many transactions similar to mine have you closed?
- What percentage of your listings actually close?
- How long do comparable businesses typically take to sell?
- How do you determine asking price or valuation?
- How will you market my business?
- Where will you look for buyers?
- Do you actively contact strategic buyers, or primarily list businesses online?
- How do you protect confidentiality?
- How do you screen buyers before giving them sensitive information?
- Who personally handles my account?
- How many active listings does that person currently manage?
- What work do you expect me to do?
- How often will I receive updates?
- How are you compensated?
- Are there upfront fees?
- Is the agreement exclusive?
- How long is the initial term?
- What is the tail period?
- What happens if I find the buyer myself?
- What happens if I decide not to sell?
- Can I speak with several former seller clients?
Also ask what they expect from you, who your day-to-day contact will be, and how they would describe your business to a buyer. If their description sounds better than the business you actually run, that is worth noticing early, because diligence will test it.
What proof to ask for
- Completed transactions, with dates and sale prices where they can share them
- Transactions reasonably comparable to yours in size, industry, and structure
- Two or three seller references, and actually call them
- Examples of marketing packages and information memorandums with confidential details removed
- A clear explanation of how they source and reach buyers
- A realistic valuation discussion, including what would make the number lower
- Evidence of process: reporting cadence, buyer logs, updates, and how questions are tracked
The reverse is worth saying too. The intermediary who tells you your business is worth less than you hoped may be the honest one. Ask them to show their reasoning and their comparables. If they can, that is evidence. If they cannot, that is evidence as well.
Red flags
- Guarantees of a specific sale price, a buyer, or a timeline
- Pressure to sign immediately
- Reluctance to explain fees clearly, in writing
- A vague marketing plan, or marketing with no named buyer groups
- Little relevant transaction experience in your size and industry
- Slow or inconsistent communication before you are even a client
- No clear process for screening buyers before they receive sensitive information
- Large upfront fees with no clear explanation of the work they pay for
- Telling you what you want to hear instead of discussing risks, timing, or pricing reality
- Treating every buyer as equally credible, regardless of financing or seriousness
- Encouraging you to focus only on headline price
What you should not delegate
Even with an excellent intermediary, you remain the owner of the outcome. Delegating the process is fine. Delegating your understanding is not.
- Your own financials: revenue, SDE, add-backs, and the story behind any unusual year
- Your desired outcome: what this sale is actually for
- Acceptable deal structure: cash, note, earnout, rollover, and what you will not accept
- Minimum acceptable economics: the number below which you would rather not sell
- Your tolerance for seller financing and post-closing risk
- Transition expectations: how long you will stay, and in what role
- Employee concerns: what you want to be true for them
- Confidentiality priorities: who must not hear about this, and how that is enforced
- Tax, legal, and accounting advice from your own qualified advisers, not from the intermediary
Managing the relationship once you have hired someone
A good intermediary relationship is managed, not assumed. Set expectations at the start, then review the evidence on a regular schedule.
- A communication cadence: a weekly update, a monthly report, or whatever you agree
- Reporting expectations: inquiries, qualified buyers, and site visits
- Buyer feedback: what buyers say after they learn more about the business
- The number and quality of inquiries, and where they came from
- How buyers are qualified before they receive information
- The reasons buyers decline, in their own words
- Changes in market response after pricing, positioning, or a material change
- When and how pricing, positioning, or marketing should be reconsidered
Then decide from evidence rather than emotion. No qualified inquiries in two months is a pricing or marketing signal. Many conversations and no offers is usually a positioning or buyer-quality signal. Several offers you do not like is a different conversation, and often a useful one.
When a strong intermediary is worth the fee
- •Buyer access beyond your own network
- •Confidentiality and controlled disclosure
- •Managing several buyers at once
- •Negotiation experience and deal structure
- •Keeping the process moving when it stalls
- •Filtering out buyers who cannot close
- •Letting you keep running the business
- •Coordinating attorneys, lenders, and CPAs
- •You already have a credible, identified buyer
- •A family transfer
- •An employee or management transition
- •A carefully structured off-market transaction
- •A small, simple business where your network is the buyer pool
Before You Hire a Broker
- Define your own goals first
- Interview multiple qualified intermediaries
- Understand every fee
- Understand exclusivity and termination
- Understand the tail period
- Ask how buyers will actually be found
- Ask how buyers will be screened
- Check relevant transaction experience
- Speak with references
- Compare proposed valuation logic
- Understand who will personally manage the listing
- Have material agreements reviewed by appropriate counsel
- Choose based on process, fit, competence, and alignment, not simply the highest promised price
- What I need from an intermediary, in plain words
- What matters most to me in this sale: my two or three non-negotiables
- Questions I want to ask every intermediary
- Deal terms I care about: cash, structure, timing, transition
- Concerns I want addressed before I sign anything
External resources open in a new tab. BizSellerHQ does not endorse every opinion expressed by outside creators.
For your eyes only — questions for your CPA, things to fix, buyer concerns.
Create a free account so BizSellerHQ can remember your business, your Academy progress, your priorities, and your next steps.
Your anonymous work is preserved when you sign up.
